AMERICA'S BEST CHOCOLATE

America's Number 1 Selling Chocolate

What is America's Number 1 Selling Chocolate?

Let's cut to the chase: it's Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, no contest. Seriously, they rake in over $1.2 billion every single year. For decades, that perfect sweet-salty combo, the familiar wrapper, and the fact you can grab them anywhere have made Reese's a total classic.

But... maybe you're thinking: "Is there more out there?"

You're definitely not alone! More and more chocolate fans are discovering this whole amazing world of artisan chocolate. It’s less about grabbing a quick fix and more about experiencing flavor, craftsmanship, and even the story behind the bar.

Mass-Market vs. Artisan: Two Very Different Worlds (Both Awesome!)

Hey, Reese's has its place! It's consistent, nostalgic, and super easy to find. But if you're feeling curious and want to dive deeper? Artisan chocolate opens up a whole new door:

  • Taste the World: Single-origin bars let the beans shine. Chocolate from Madagascar? Often bursts with bright red berry tartness. Ecuador? Might surprise you with floral, honeyed notes. Peru? Could hint at nuts or dried fruit. It's like geography in your mouth!
  • Real Craftsmanship: Think small batches, hands-on work. Artisans roast, grind, and conche the chocolate themselves (often called "bean-to-bar"). They hand-pour bars, decorate bonbons by hand, and play with incredible flavors – think dark chocolate with sea salt, raspberry, or even cardamom. No weird additives, just good stuff.
  • It Feels Good Too: Many small makers really care about where their beans come from. They often pay farmers way more than the big guys (like 2-5 times more!), support sustainable farming that protects the environment, and even help save rare types of cacao trees.

Why Try Artisan Chocolate?

Think of it this way: Reese's is the catchy pop song you can't help but sing along to. Artisan chocolate is like the jazz record that made you fall in love with music and opened your ears to the beauty of nuances and complexities. Here's why:

  • Flavor Profiles You Can't Find on Aisle 7: Artisan chocolate is about unique profiles of flavors, interesting inclusions, and pure, simple, (and high quality) ingredients. 
  • You Can Taste the Care: A normal chocolate bar may be neutral in flavor, but knowing a person has poured their heart, mind, and soul into making your chocolate bar taste even better!
  • Gifts That Actually Wow: Forget the ordinary.

Speaking of Gifts... Artisan Chocolate Shines!

Looking for a present that feels truly special? Gourmet chocolate gifts from small makers are perfect:

  • Stunning Presentation: Handcrafted boxes, beautiful wrappers, eco-friendly materials – it feels luxurious.
  • Unique & Memorable: Give truffles with lavender honey, bars with exotic spices, or bonbons with surprising fillings. People remember this stuff!
  • A Story to Tell: Many come with notes about the beans or the maker's mission – it adds a personal touch. Perfect for birthdays, thank-yous, or just treating yourself mindfully.

Ready to Dip Your Toe In? (No Pressure!)

Whether you're a die-hard Reese's fan or just chocolate-curious, now's a great time to explore! Forget snobbery – it's about finding new things you might love. Places like Cacao & Cardamom make it easy to find approachable, exciting options:

  • Love Dark Chocolate? Try a smooth, complex bar (70-85%) from Colombia or Tanzania.
  • Feeling Adventurous? Grab a bar with cool inclusions like matcha, orange blossom, or crunchy nuts.
  • Need a Gift? Check out curated collections of bonbons or themed boxes – they always impress.

The Bottom Line?

Reese's will always be an American icon, and rightly so! But if you ever find yourself craving:

  • Deeper, more interesting flavors...
  • Simpler, cleaner ingredients...
  • Or a closer connection to how your chocolate is made...

...then the world of artisan chocolate is ready to welcome you with open arms (and delicious bars!). It's all about delicious discoveries – no judgment, just pure enjoyment.

What is the #1 selling chocolate candy in the US?



By Sandeep Pamnani

In #1 chocolate candy, Artisan chocolate, Artisan chocolaterie, Best gourmet chocolate, Fine chocolate, Gourmet chocolate gifts, Gourmet dark chocolates, Small-batch chocolate
Back to blog